Pumpkin Spice and Everything Nice

It’s that time of year again, we’re rounding the corner into fall and I couldn’t be happier! Cooler brisk weather, changing tree colors, pumpkin spice lattes. That last part is yet another one of my addictions. Pumpkin spice, oh how I love you! I count down the days until the PSL makes its fall debut at Starbucks and then proceed to spend way way too much money on such a simple pleasure. This fall season, I’m trying to live within our means and not blow our entire discretionary fund on Starbucks. So, I thought I would would try my hand at making my own pumpkin spice syrup! Thanks to my slight ridiculous addiction to Pinterest, I was able to quickly find a recipe that seemed entirely foolproof. I’m happy to announce that it was indeed pretty simple and boy oh boy…it’s pretty amazing!

The ingredients are really quite simple and most people will have the majority of them in their pantry. I, however, am still building up my spice cabinet so I had to run to our local and eclectic Safeway to grab a few items.

Side tangent, This was a real conversation I had with a certain quirky sales clerk at our local Safeway:
Me: “Excuse me, where can I find pumpkin puree?”
Clerk (completely serious): “Oh, we don’t carry pumpkin. The FDA has removed it from our shelves because it isn’t safe for human consumption anymore. Sorry.”
Me (totally shocked and slightly confused): “Oh! Um…well. Really? Wow, that’s crazy. You mean all pumpkin isn’t safe anymore?”
Clerk: “Yep. Sorry”
Me: “Well, that kinda ruins everything…”
Clerk: “Oh, I’m just kidding…it’s over here.”
Me: “Awkward…”

Turns out they only had pumpkin pie filling because their warehouse had just burned down. I’m still trying to figure out if that was true or if quirky over there was trying to pull another fast one on me. Oh Felton Safeway, you never cease to amaze me…

After getting my pumpkin puree from another local store, I was set and ready to go! Here’s the recipe that I followed (found over here. I did tweak it slightly  and in hindsight I would make more adjustments- more on that later):

Pumpkin Spice Syrup:

  • 1 1/2 cups water
  • 1 1/2 cups sugar
  • 4 cinnamon sticks (or 1 teaspoon of ground cinnamon)
  • 1/2 teaspoon ground cloves
  • 1/2 teaspoon ground ginger*
  • 1 teaspoon ground nutmeg
  • 3 tablespoons pumpkin purée*
  1. Combine water and sugar over medium heat. Stir until sugar is completely dissolved
  2. Whisk in remaining ingredients and heat for about 6 minutes, stirring frequently (try not to let the mixture boil)
  3. Turn off and let cool for a few moments
  4. Strain the mixture through cheesecloth and/or through a fine mesh strainer
  5. Pour mixture into a  glass container and store in refrigerator (it should be good for about a month…I DOUBT mine will last that long though!)
  6. Enjoy 1-2 tablespoons with your favorite brewed coffee. Or if you’re fancy pants- enjoy with a homemade latte!

I dusted off the ol’ Barista machine and steamed some milk and pulled a few shots. Boy, I sure do miss my barista days at the bux (minus the smelling like milk and chai syrup all the time…I don’t miss that). I finished it off with a sprinkle of cinnamon/sugar and the final product was simply delicious! If you noticed above, there were two ingredients with a * next to them. In my next batch, I’ll adjust these by possibly omitting the ginger and definitely increasing the pumpkin for more pumpkiny goodness. I say, make it once and then tweak it to make it your own. This batch is great, but there is always room for improvement.

Here are some shots of the entire process:

I’m definitely not brand loyal when it comes to certain things like spices…especially when the Safeway brand of ground ginger is half the price of McCormick!

The syrup pre-straining:

It’s really important to strain the grainy spices out of the syrup. Prior to this I ran it through a double layer of cheese cloth, but it didn’t seem to catch as much as I would have liked. Why is there a rubber band around the measuring cup, you might ask? Because I tried to strain the mixture through a coffee filter before I remembered that I had a fine mesh strainer. Don’t try the coffee filter trick…it doesn’t work! The syrup just sits there because it’s half sugar and too thick to filter through. Great idea, but not the outcome I was hoping for! haha…And here’s my finished product!! Enough pumpkin spice syrup to last me a week or two (maybe even longer if I stretch it…hah, unlikely).

This took me all of 15 minutes to make and will save me a ton of mula and trips to Starbucks! I need to remember that I have an espresso machine sitting on my counter just asking to be used! I’m looking forward to adding a spoonful of this syrup to my basic brewed coffee to test it out too. I’m assuming that it’ll be just as awesome, but that’s my opinion :)

Also, I have almost an entire can of pumpkin in my fridge just waiting to be used…chocolate chip pumpkin muffins maybe? How about pumpkin pancakes? Pumpkin cookies? Oh, the possibilities are endless! :)

In pumpkin heaven,
Mrs. Edwards


8 thoughts on “Pumpkin Spice and Everything Nice

  1. Sarah Klein (@bsarahklein) Reply

    I made this last Saturday with Stevia in the Raw (so it was Sugar Free) and it was pretty much the same! A new favorite recipe for sure :)

    1. terramichele Reply

      Oh Stevia is a great idea! I’ll have to try that next time. This recipe definitely hasn’t improved my addiction to pumpkin spice one bit…but hopefully it’ll curb the spending at Starbucks :)

  2. Heather Reply

    Terra, Safeway did have a fire at one of the warehouses. It was last Friday and it is effecting most nor cal Safeway’s!

    1. terramichele Reply

      Glad to know I wasn’t actually as gullible as I thought I was :)

  3. wendy saunders Reply

    so excited to make this today! I love pumpkin flavor so off your notes I added more pumpkin… then more til I reached 1.5 cups purreed pumkin (I roasted myself since AUS doesnt have canned pumpkin) but i had doubled the simple syrup. so all in all I used 3 cups sugar, 3 cups water, 4 sticks cinnamon with 1 tsp ground, 3/4 tsp ground cloves, 1T ground ginger, 1tsp ground nutmeg, and 1.5 cups canned pumpkin. it tastes amazing! I am so happy to have a piece of autumn here in Aussie spring. thanks for being the guinea pig!

    1. terramichele Reply

      Wow, Wendy! You really must love pumpkin to roast it yourself! I’m so glad that I could be inspiration/guinea pig :) That amount should last you a little while, I hope you enjoy in thoroughly!!

  4. [...] have picked up on this at some point, but pumpkin is possibly my most favorite flavor. It’s good i... simplymrsedwards.wordpress.com/2012/11/06/crock-pot-pumpkin-spice-oatmeal
  5. […] couple of years ago, I brought you a recipe for Pumpkin Spice Coffee Syrup. Although that recipe is ... simplymrsedwards.com/2013/09/22/fall-is-my-favorite

Leave a Reply